|
Home > Archive > Home Repair forum > November 2005 > Home Heating
You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread.
To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to
this thread please [click here]
|
|
| dianne gigler 2005-11-10, 6:21 pm |
| My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system powered by
natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of natural gas, I
would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power the hot water system.
I have searched the internet and have found nothing. Am I looking for
something that does not exist or cannot be done? Any help and/or leads
will be appreciated. Thank you.
| |
| Paul Franklin 2005-11-10, 6:21 pm |
| On Thu, 10 Nov 2005 16:33:12 -0500, dianne gigler <dlg@andrew.cmu.edu>
wrote:
>My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system powered by
>natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of natural gas, I
>would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power the hot water system.
>I have searched the internet and have found nothing. Am I looking for
>something that does not exist or cannot be done? Any help and/or leads
>will be appreciated. Thank you.
Here's one: http://www.yukon-eagle.com/
Try searching for "wood fired boiler" and you'll find some others.
Not going to be cheap to switch over...
HTH,
Paul
| |
|
|
"dianne gigler" <dlg@andrew.cmu.edu> wrote in message
news:26638CE15DFF655E0EE7381B@dlgcmu.WV.CC.CMU.EDU...
> My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system powered by
> natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of natural gas, I
> would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power the hot water system.
> I have searched the internet and have found nothing. Am I looking for
> something that does not exist or cannot be done? Any help and/or leads
> will be appreciated. Thank you.
First and foremost are you handy with electrical and mechanical products?
Call a local licensed contractor and see what they can put together for you.
Adding another fuel source will certainly complicate the situation. I am
always up for a challenge, I know some great controls guys in the Midwest.
I know your not talking about my neck of the woods, cause we are pretty much
interested in cooling only.
Questions you need to answer,
Does your local area have "no burn days"?
Are you ready to commit to the labor and effort that it is going to take to
deal with wood?
What does a cord of wood cost? (4'x4'x 8' or 128 cubic feet)
What kind of wood can you get for what cost? Different woods burn
differently.
Have you checked the insulation in your home recently? last couple of years.
google to one of the .gov sites and see what they recommend for your area.
I added R-30 to my home in July, August's a/c bill was 50% less. (my home
circa 1977)
WAG your talking about a several thousand dollars to get started. Money
might be spent better upgrading the system you have.
| |
| Edwin Pawlowski 2005-11-10, 7:21 pm |
| "dianne gigler" <dlg@andrew.cmu.edu> wrote in message
news:26638CE15DFF655E0EE7381B@dlgcmu.WV.CC.CMU.EDU...
> My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system powered by
> natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of natural gas, I
> would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power the hot water system.
> I have searched the internet and have found nothing. Am I looking for
> something that does not exist or cannot be done? Any help and/or leads
> will be appreciated. Thank you.
There are dual fuel and wood boilers. Look for wood fired boilers.
Plenty of links of this site
http://www.motherearthnews.com/top_...ed_Central_Heat
http://www.woodheat.org/technology/outboiler.htm
http://www.wvu.edu/~agexten/forestry/fact16.pdf
Before you jump in and spend a lot of money, assess your situation
carefully. Wood is also going up in price and may not save you much. Will
you have to buy it or will you be able to cut it for "free", meaning only a
few hundred dollars for a chainsaw and equipment. Are you prepared to do
the labor? I've burned wood for many years, but the past couple and even
this year, I'm buying oil. If you are near a sawmill, you may be able to
buy slabs cheaply.
Most likely, it is already too late for this year. Every wood dealer in my
area has sold all the dry wood a month or more ago. Green wood is cheaper
to buy, but heats far less so it is more expensive to use.
--
Ed
http://pages.cthome.net/edhome/
| |
| Joseph Meehan 2005-11-10, 9:21 pm |
| dianne gigler wrote:
> My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system
> powered by natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of
> natural gas, I would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power
> the hot water system. I have searched the internet and have found
> nothing. Am I looking for something that does not exist or cannot be
> done? Any help and/or leads will be appreciated. Thank you.
My suggestion is to forget the whole thing unless you have access to
good free wood. In most situations where you don't get your wood free, it
is often the most expensive fuel. As natural gas goes up the demand for
wood is going to go up and it will increase in price. In the mean time you
will have your hardware expense and you are not likely to recover that cost.
--
Joseph Meehan
Dia duit
| |
| wkearney99 2005-11-11, 11:21 am |
| > Money might be spent better upgrading the system you have.
Or, look at it this way, improve your overall insulation before upgrading.
That way if the savings aren't "enough" then when you do upgrade it'll be
even more efficient.
First thing to check would be the current furnace. If you're not already
using a high-efficiency gas furnance then you might want to upgrade.
Wood is never inexpensive enough, or plentiful enough, in most places to
justify itself. Unless you've got a steady supply of free wood, and the
patience to keep stoking it, it's not going to be worth the hassle.
Upgrade your overall insulation and make sure your furnace is efficient
FIRST.
| |
| barry@sme-online.com 2005-11-11, 5:21 pm |
| Standard stuff you need first:
clock-thermostat, with max setbacks possible. (Electric blankets for
the pampered.)
aquastat setting as low as will work. (maybe 130F vice 180F, and varied
by month.)
automatic stack damper. (can give you 50% savings)
These can yield 40-60% savings for small, one-time charge.
Zone-off areas where heat is not needed. Like, even with Alum foil rad
jacket.
Seal around all doors and windows, tightly. And find and plug all the
other leaks, paying special attention to those at upper and lower
extremities of house. Chimney effect. This is really cheap, makes
things v. comfortable w/quick payback.
Layer-on more attic insulation if advisable.
That's pretty much it for the quick-payback, cheap stuff.
Next would be insulation in exterior walls. Replacing old mouse-fur
insulation for full-thickness R-13 makes a huge difference.
Single pane windows are candidate for high-e inserts. Another huge
difference.
Additional heat source like pellet, corn, or wood stove might now come
into play. Most simply for heating air. Many pellet stoves can vent
through wall. Forget this year, and plan ahead. For when stoves and
pellets will again be available. (Pellet stoves are also v.
low-emissions and ~90 or more % efficient, from tech data.) Wood stoves
meet needs of some of us just fine, those used to chainsaw, maul, and
sweat.
Forget trying to put this in essentially uninsulated masonry basement,
or plan on insulating stove area.
Enjoy staying warm,
J
| |
| HeatMan 2005-11-11, 5:21 pm |
|
"dianne gigler" <dlg@andrew.cmu.edu> wrote in message
news:26638CE15DFF655E0EE7381B@dlgcmu.WV.CC.CMU.EDU...
> My house is heated by a radiator based hot water heating system powered by
> natural gas. Given the expected increase in the cost of natural gas, I
> would like to add an auxiliary wood burner to power the hot water system.
> I have searched the internet and have found nothing. Am I looking for
> something that does not exist or cannot be done? Any help and/or leads
> will be appreciated. Thank you.
Yes it can be done.
You need to set up a primary/secondary system. You need a loop so that both
boilers can feed into. Then the 2 boilers, the gas and the wood, will feed
into the loop and the radiator load will feed off the loop. For best
operation, the wood boiler will need to go through a heat exchanger to
hydraulically uncouple the wood boiler from the rest of the system.
I hope you already have the wood fired boiler, because several manufacturers
are promising delivery of boilers in February, if they were ordered in mid
October.
I hope you have some money, because to do it right it's gonna cost about 2
grand or more, just for materials without the cost of the boiler.
Good Luck.
| |
| Edwin Pawlowski 2005-11-11, 7:21 pm |
| <barry@sme-online.com> wrote in message
> Standard stuff you need first:
> clock-thermostat, with max setbacks possible. (Electric blankets for
> the pampered.)
Hey, stop calling me names. I'm just a sensitive guy that likes getting my
naked (and sexy, IMO) body in between nice warm sheets. Just because my wife
turns the blanket on for me about an hour before bed time does not mean I'm
pampered.
--
Ed
http://pages.cthome.net/edhome/
|
|
|
|
|