Home > Archive > Home Repair forum > July 2005 > hvac duct insulation









You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread. To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to this thread please [click here]

 

Author hvac duct insulation
Jim

2005-07-19, 6:25 pm

The hvac supply ducts in my attic are insulated and have a black cover.
The ducts in the basement have a silver cover. Is this normal? Or
does it matter? I would have thought that the black covered insulation
in the attic would absorb attic heat and increase the temperature of
the air supply.

-Jim

HeatMan

2005-07-19, 6:26 pm

Is it Flex duct?


"Jim" <jrboddie@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1121801430.848875.322570@g44g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
quote:

> The hvac supply ducts in my attic are insulated and have a black cover.
> The ducts in the basement have a silver cover. Is this normal? Or
> does it matter? I would have thought that the black covered insulation
> in the attic would absorb attic heat and increase the temperature of
> the air supply.
>
> -Jim
>



Jim

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm

Yes.

HeatMan

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm


"Jim" <jrboddie@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1121805945.553019.40950@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
quote:

> Yes.
>


Some flex has got a plastic vapor barrier and some has a metalized
barrier....


RichK

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm


"Jim" <jrboddie@gmail.com> wrote in message
quote:

> The hvac supply ducts in my attic are insulated and have a black

cover.
quote:

> The ducts in the basement have a silver cover. Is this normal? Or
> does it matter? I would have thought that the black covered

insulation
quote:

> in the attic would absorb attic heat and increase the temperature of
> the air supply.


Timely question. I wanted to insulate the ducts in my garage. Have
seen the black, but wondered it it's just garbage bags or sheet
plastic stapled over normal attic fiberglass R11 or similar.

Anyone have a suggestion on what to use? Mine are normal galvanized
ducts, some rectangular and some round.

Local Home Depot looks at me funny, when I ask about it.

Rich

Jim

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm

Would one be preferred in an attic over the other?

Thanks for replying.

-Jim

RP

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm



Jim wrote:
quote:

> Would one be preferred in an attic over the other?
>
> Thanks for replying.


Flex duct is not to be preferred period. But to answer your question:
It's the R value that matters, not the color.

hvacrmedic


Stretch

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm

RP,
Flex duct is easier to seal and usually performs better thermally.
Sheet metal will pass more air with the same static pressure. Flex
duct is quieter.

It is a trade off, depending on your situation.

With sheet metal, to have a tight system, you must seal every gore on
every elbow. You must seal every joint in the duct, plus you must seal
every longitudinal seam. Then you hust do the same thing with the
wrap. And if you install the wrap tight so it looks nice, the actual
R-value is about 1/2 rated value.

With flex duct, you just have to seal the connections at the ends, but
it must be supported at closer intervals with wider straps. But you
get full rated R-value for the entite length.

Stretch

RP

2005-07-19, 11:25 pm



Stretch wrote:
quote:

> RP,
> Flex duct is easier to seal and usually performs better thermally.
> Sheet metal will pass more air with the same static pressure. Flex
> duct is quieter.
>
> It is a trade off, depending on your situation.
>
> With sheet metal, to have a tight system, you must seal every gore on
> every elbow. You must seal every joint in the duct, plus you must seal
> every longitudinal seam. Then you hust do the same thing with the
> wrap. And if you install the wrap tight so it looks nice, the actual
> R-value is about 1/2 rated value.
>
> With flex duct, you just have to seal the connections at the ends, but
> it must be supported at closer intervals with wider straps. But you
> get full rated R-value for the entite length.


Which is why it isn't legal here except for drops.

hvacrmedic

TURTLE

2005-07-24, 9:06 pm


"Jim" <jrboddie@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1121808947.162611.144270@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
> Would one be preferred in an attic over the other?
>
> Thanks for replying.
>
> -Jim
>


This is Turtle

if I was going to use Flex Duct. It would be the Black for it is made to be sun
resistant and not crack or fall a part like the silver will in sun light.

TURTLE


Jim

2005-07-24, 9:06 pm

Thank you all.

-JIm

HeatMan

2005-07-24, 9:07 pm


"Jim" <jrboddie@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1121808947.162611.144270@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
> Would one be preferred in an attic over the other?
>
> Thanks for replying.
>
> -Jim
>


Stretch and RP answered before I could and their answers were the same mine
would have been.

I don't really care for flex because of the way it's usually run. It also
has a higher resistance than the same size hard pipe.


LinkBot





Other archives available: Cellular phones topics archive | Web Design forum archive | Software help archive | Hardware reviews archive | Programming topics archive

Copyright 2004 - 2009 homeownerschat.com